Copycat Panera Mac & Cheese

Instructions:

  1. Start by bringing a large pot of water to a rolling boil over high heat, then season it with 1 tablespoon kosher salt to enhance the pasta’s flavor.
  2. Add 1 pound of medium pasta shells to the boiling water and stir immediately to prevent sticking. Cook them until just al dente, about 8–10 minutes, stirring occasionally.
  3. Reserve ¼ cup of the starchy pasta cooking water before draining the shells, which helps adjust the sauce’s consistency later.
  4. Drain the pasta thoroughly but do not rinse it, as the starch on the pasta helps the cheese sauce cling better.
  5. Return the drained pasta to the empty cooking pot and toss with 1 tablespoon unsalted butter until melted and the shells are lightly coated. Set aside.
  6. Warm 2 cups whole milk and 1 cup heavy cream until hot but not boiling; this prevents lumps and helps the sauce blend smoothly.
  7. In a heavy-bottomed saucepan over medium heat, melt 4 tablespoons unsalted butter without browning it to maintain the sauce’s pale color.
  8. Whisk in ¼ cup all-purpose flour immediately, cooking the roux for 1–2 minutes until it loses its raw flour aroma but stays pale.
  9. Slowly whisk in the warmed milk in three additions, making sure the mixture becomes smooth and free of lumps before adding more.
  10. Stir in the warmed heavy cream, then reduce heat to medium-low and cook gently for 3–4 minutes until the sauce thickens enough to coat the back of a spoon.
  11. Add 1 teaspoon Dijon mustard, ½ teaspoon garlic powder, ¼ teaspoon onion powder, ¼ teaspoon white pepper, optional smoked paprika, and ¼ teaspoon kosher salt. Whisk well to combine.
  12. Lower the heat and add chopped white American cheese a few pieces at a time, stirring gently until fully melted and incorporated, creating a silky base.
  13. Remove the pan from heat, then gradually stir in freshly shredded sharp white cheddar in thirds, allowing each addition to melt completely to avoid graininess.
  14. If the sauce becomes too thick, thin it with a splash of warm milk or reserved pasta water; if too thin, let it rest briefly to thicken slightly.
  15. Taste and adjust seasoning with a little more salt or white pepper as needed to balance the flavors.
  16. Pour half of the cheese sauce over the pasta shells in the pot and fold gently with a silicone spatula to coat without breaking the pasta.
  17. Add the remaining sauce and fold carefully until every shell is evenly coated and filled with creamy sauce, adding reserved pasta water if necessary to reach a luxurious consistency.
  18. Warm the combined mac and cheese over very low heat for 30–60 seconds if needed, stirring gently—but avoid boiling to prevent sauce separation.
  19. Remove from heat and let rest for about 1 minute so the sauce clings beautifully to the shells.
  20. Spoon the mac and cheese into a serving bowl, arranging the shells naturally to showcase their glossy, creamy coating.
  21. Serve immediately for the best texture and appearance, ensuring the sauce stays smooth, glossy, and rich.

Variations

  • For a richer sauce, substitute ¼ cup of whole milk with extra heavy cream to increase creaminess.
  • Use extra-sharp white cheddar for a bolder, more pronounced cheese flavor, keeping some white American cheese for smooth texture.
  • Replace white American cheese with another smooth melting cheese like fontina or Gouda if unavailable, noting the texture will vary slightly.
  • Make a lighter version by increasing the proportion of whole milk and reducing the heavy cream.
  • For a kid-friendly version, reduce the Dijon mustard to soften the tang and use a milder white cheddar.
  • Add a crispy breadcrumb topping and bake briefly for a crunchy finish, though this deviates from the classic creamy style.

Tips

  • Cook the pasta just until al dente because it will continue to soften when mixed with the warm sauce, preventing mushy shells.
  • Reserve some pasta cooking water before draining to adjust sauce thickness and help it cling perfectly.
  • Warm the milk and cream before adding them to the roux to avoid lumps and ensure a silky sauce.
  • Shred cheese fresh from a block for smoother melting; pre-shredded cheese often contains anti-caking agents that hinder melting.
  • Store leftover mac and cheese in an airtight container in the refrigerator and consume within 3–4 days for best quality.
  • Reheat leftovers gently on the stove over low heat with a splash of milk, stirring constantly to restore creaminess without separating.
  • Freezing is possible but may slightly affect texture; thaw overnight in the fridge and reheat slowly with added milk to regain creaminess.
Rate this recipe
☆☆☆☆☆
Not yet rated